Game
Prisoner’s Dilemma
Each player has a reason to defect, even though both would do better if both cooperated.
The model
Two players choose simultaneously. Mutual cooperation pays 3 each. A lone defector gets 5 and the cooperator gets 0. Mutual defection pays 1 each.
What the model predicts
Defect strictly dominates Cooperate for both players because 5 beats 3 and 1 beats 0. Mutual defection is the unique Nash equilibrium, even though mutual cooperation pays both more.
| Cooperate | Defect | |
|---|---|---|
| Cooperate | ||
| Defect |
Try it
Everyday situations
- Two colleagues each gain time by leaving a shared cleanup to the other, although both prefer a clean handoff.
- Two shops can protect margins at regular prices, but either can win customers by secretly discounting.
- Two teams gain from exchanging forecasts, yet either can retain an advantage by withholding its own.
- Two jurisdictions benefit from lower pollution, while each saves compliance costs by delaying its own reductions.
- Two housemates each enjoy a tidy kitchen and prefer the other to do the work.
What changes the result
- If the same players expect to meet again, future losses can outweigh the gain from defecting today.
- A penalty greater than 2 on every defection makes cooperation strictly dominant in this matrix.
Practical insight
Identify the private payoff from defecting before asking people to cooperate. A rule that changes that payoff can change the outcome.