Skip to content

Game family

Tragedy of the Commons

Each user captures the benefit of taking more from a shared resource and bears only part of the damage.

The model

Two users independently choose whether to take one extra unit from a shared stock. The extra unit pays its taker 4, but each extra unit causes depletion costing each user 3.

What the model predicts

Taking more raises the taker’s net payoff by 1 regardless of what the other user does. Both take more in equilibrium and each loses 2 relative to both restraining.

Player A chooses a row. Player B chooses a column. Select an outcome to compare their incentives.
RestrainTake more
Restrain
Take more

Try it

How much does one additional unit change the two players’ combined payoff?
Explore the interactive model

Everyday situations

  • Boats take extra fish while the loss of breeding stock affects the whole fleet.
  • Farms pump from an aquifer whose declining water table affects every well.
  • Services send more requests to a shared API and increase latency for everyone.
  • Teams reserve extra rooms because unused holds cost them little and block colleagues.
  • Herders add livestock to shared pasture where overgrazing reduces forage for all.

What changes the result

  • A higher private share of the damage can reverse the incentive to extract.
  • Users can sustain different outcomes with locally enforced quotas, monitoring, or resource rights.

Practical insight

Give users a way to observe aggregate use and a reason to account for the costs their withdrawals impose on others.

Further reading

More in collective action