Skip to content
All articles

Blog

How auction rules change a bid

The winning bid and the amount paid can be governed by different rules.

Pay your bid

If your value is 60 and you bid 45 in a first-price auction, winning leaves you with 15. Raising the bid can make a win more likely and cuts what you earn from a win. The entry’s half-value bidding rule follows from its specific assumptions about the number of bidders and how values are distributed.

Pay the next bid

Suppose your value is 80 and the highest competing bid is 55. In a second-price auction, bidding 80 wins at 55. If the highest competing bid exceeds your value, bidding your value keeps you from winning a loss. These cases explain why truthful bidding is weakly dominant in the private-value model.

Pay even when you lose

When everyone pays, a bid of 4 loses 4 if someone else bids 6. A pitch competition can resemble this when every entrant spends time on work that has little value outside the contest. If the work can be reused, the cost of losing is lower than the hours spent might suggest.

Explore the models